Cultivating Understanding Through Children’s Books
As the state, country, and world contend both with the over-representation of Black Americans among those dying from COVID-19, among those incarcerated for non-violent crimes, and among those experiencing violence from law enforcement officers, we are all reeling. This week’s global response—through protests, boycotts, and on social media—reminds us at PRIME TIME that we cannot forget what children are experiencing at this moment in time.
There are the personal experiences of children like the 6-year-old daughter of George Floyd, who have lost a father at the hands of police officers. There are the indirect, though still significant experiences of children listening to the news in the background, overhearing adult conversations, or marching in the streets with their parents. These experiences call for direct and often difficult conversations like those that are at the heart of PRIME TIME Family Reading programs.
Reading and discussing quality children’s books and the humanities themes found within them, together—parent/caregiver and child—can provide a launching point for conversations that cultivate understanding. Over the coming weeks, PRIME TIME will be sharing titles from our award-winning book series on our Facebook page, along with guiding questions to support meaningful conversations. We hope that you will join us in those conversations online, and, more importantly, at home. We offer up the following PRIME TIME titles and themes to get the conversation started.
The True Story of the Three Little Pigs by Jon Scieszka and Lane Smith
This the classic story of The Three Little Pigs but told from the perspective of Alexander T. Wolf. While baking a chocolate cake for his grandmother’s birthday, our protagonist realizes that he is out of sugar and decides to see if his neighbors might loan him some. Unfortunately, he is suffering from a cold, and accidentally blows the first and second Little Pigs’ houses down with a powerful sneeze. Because the Little Pigs had died in the destruction, Wolf decides to eat them in order to not let a “perfectly good ham dinner go to waste.” By the time he gets to the third Little Pig’s house (which was made of bricks), Wolf is treated rudely when asking for a cup of sugar. Wolf is provoked into a sneezing rage. The third Little Pig reports Wolf to the police and is sentenced to ten millenniums in prison.
Ask a child:
If you were a judge in a court, would you find the wolf guilty? Why or why not? What in his story would make you believe him or not believe him?
Why Mosquitoes Buzz in Peoples Ears by Verna Aardema
In this origin story, the mosquito lies to a lizard, who puts sticks in his ears and ends up frightening another animal, which down a long line causes a panic. In the end, an owlet is killed and the owl is too sad to wake the sun until the animals hold court and find out who is responsible. The mosquito is eventually found out, but it hides in order to escape punishment. So now it constantly buzzes in people’s ears to find out if everyone is still angry at it.
Ask a child:
Who do you think was really to blame for the sun’s not rising? Whom did the animals think was to blame? Do you think they were right? Why or why not? If you were on a jury and all the animals were arrested for the crime, which one (or ones?) would you find guilty? Why?
Amazing Grace by Mary Hoffman
Grace loves stories; especially acting them out. So when her teacher tells the class that they will be performing a play about Peter Pan, she jumps at the chance to take on the leading role. But her classmates tell her she can’t play the role because she doesn’t look like Peter Pan. This doesn’t sit well with determined Grace, who, with the support of her family and a spark of inspiration from an actress who plays roles that don’t look like her, pushes past the judgments of her peers.
Ask a child:
Have you ever been told you can’t do something because of the way you look? How did that make you feel? What would you do differently if you had the chance to relive that experience?
Everett Anderson’s Goodbye by Lucille Clifton
The winner of the 1984 Coretta Scott King Author Award, Everett Anderson’s Goodbye tells the story of a young Black American boy who is trying to come to grips with his father’s death. Everett moves through a range of emotions—denial, anger, despair—before coming to accept the loss of his father. The illustrations and spare text capture the vivid emotions tied to grief, and also the difficulty with articulating those emotions through language.
Ask a child:
This is a sad book. Did you like it? Do you prefer sad books or happy ones? Why do you think authors write sad books?
Why does Everett say he doesn’t love his family or candy or Santa Claus or his mother anymore? Does he mean it?
Click, Clack, Moo: Cows That Type by Doreen Cronin
After finding an old typewriter in the barn, a group of cows begin typing letters to their farmer to inform him that they are dissatisfied with their working conditions (the barn is cold and they would like electric blankets). The farmer refuses to address their demands. Later, he finds another letter on the barn door that says, “Sorry. We’re closed. No milk today.” With “duck” acting as mediator, the two parties eventually reach a compromise. Unfortunately for the farmer, another group of animals finds the typewriter and follows the lead of the cows.
Ask a child:
Suppose you got to vote. Whose side would you be on in this story—the farmer’s side or the cows’ side? Why?
Does someone always have to lose in a conflict like this, and does someone have to win, or can both sides win? Can both sides lose? Or think about it this way: can the cows and chickens prosper without the farmer? Can the farmer prosper without the cows and chickens?
Why do you think this story is told through animals rather than people? Does this type of incident happen in the world of people? Can you think of any current examples?
